Aaron Williamson

(Who?)

DFW on unfashionable conviction

by Aaron Williamson

David Foster Wallace, with whose loss the senselessness of our time increased measurably, wrote much during the 90s that is relevant to the present political morass.1  Most literally relevant is Up, Simba, on McCain’s 2000 primary run and the appeal of that candidate’s character.2  But in the unlikely context of his review of a Dostoevsky biography, DFW also nails the importance of Obama’s campaign:

Our intelligentsia distrust strong belief, open conviction.  Material passion is one thing, but ideological passion disgusts us on some deep level.  We believe that ideology is now the province of the rival SIGs and PACs all trying to get their slice of the big green pie . . . and, looking around us, we see that indeed it is so.  But [biographer Joseph] Frank’s Dostoevsky would point out (or more like hop up and down and shake his fist and fly at us and shout) that if this is so, it’s at least partly because we have abandoned the field.  That we’ve abandoned it to fundamentalists whose pitiless rigidity and eagerness to judge show that they’re clueless about the “Christian Values” they would impose on others.  To rightist militias and conspiracy theorists whose paranoia about the government supposes the government to be just way more organized and efficient than it really is.  And, in academia and the arts, to the increasingly absurd and dogmatic Political Correctness movement, whose obsession with the mere forms of utterance and discourse show too well how effete and aestheticized our best liberal instincts have become, how removed from what’s really important — motive, feeling, belief.

I don’t think I’m a personality cultist devoted to an empty idea of “change,” because of the change I’ve seen already: Obama already reclaimed belief — ideology — from its abusers and made it more believable.  He’s not going to fix everything, in fact his administration is likely to be a disappointment.  But to restore conviction from its debased position in American politics is a real accomplishment and maybe the one I’m really voting for.

  1. Full disclosure: all of the “much” I refer to here and in fact all I’ve ever read of DFW I read in Consider the Lobster. []
  2. And most timely is DFW’s account of the McCain 2000 campaign’s implosion upon “going negative” against George Bush II. []

2 Responses to DFW on unfashionable conviction:

http://timschneider.us/ posted on October 18, 2008 at 1:15 pm:

I just want you to know, I set up my own OpenID server just so I could comment on this post.

I just re-read “Up, Simba” after everyone and their brother recommended it in the aftermath of 1) DFW’s death and 2) the implosion of McCain’s campaign/brand. The abridged Rolling Stone version is available here:
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/story/18420304/the_weasel_twelve_monkeys_and_the_shrub

Thank god I haven’t figured out how to do footnotes in my blog posts yet. It would be the end of me.

I’ve been thinking about this disclaimer at the end of your post, the “He’s not going to fix everything, in fact his administration is likely to be a disappointment.” I keep seeing this, even from people whose skin is flushed pink with the Obama KoolAid. Isn’t this a symptom of that distrust DFW describes and you quote?

It feels like dating a girl who you think is out of your league in some way. You’re all like “I can’t believe she actually is into me, this is awesome. But you know, she’ll probably get bored with me or find some other guy whose cooler, so I won’t get my hopes up. Or, I’m sure as I get to know her she’ll turn out to suck in key ways.”

I’m skeptical too, bracing for the inevitable disappointment, but maybe it’s that skepticism we should be skeptical of. Because sometimes that girl does turn out to be that awesome. And sometimes you marry her.

Matt Katz posted on October 20, 2008 at 11:00 pm:

And then the disappointment begins. Because now you are stuck with her, you poor sod. She’s starting to look a lot like her mom already, no matter how hot she looked at first.

Leave a Reply